Copyright © 2000, 1999, 1998, 1997, 1996, 1995 by The Johns Hopkins University Press E-ISSN: 1086-3338
Print ISSN: 0043-8871

Edited by the World Politics Editorial Board


World Politics 49.1, October 1996

PDF Acrobat file Articles featuring this icon are provided in Portable Document Format (PDF).
Please refer to Instructions for Reading Acrobat PDF Files for more information.

Contributors

Contents

Articles

    Londregan, John Benedict.
    Poole, Keith T.
  • Does High Income Promote Democracy? PDF Acrobat file
    Subjects:
    • Democracy -- Economic aspects.
    • Economic development -- Political aspects.
    Abstract:
    The authors construct a statistical model with which to test whether the regularity that democracy is more commonly found among wealthy countries stems from a democratizing effect of high income or is due entirely to other factors, such as the historical context, various features of the institutional setting, and simultaneity with the process of leadership change. Even after correcting for these many other influences, the democratizing effect of income remains as a statistically significant factor promoting the emergence of democratic political institutions. The authors go on to find that leaders' risks of losing power rise during their time in office and that these risks are higher in more democratic countries.

    The authors confirm the finding by Burkhart and Lewis-Beck that the democracy-promoting effect of income is stronger among the European countries. They suggest that high income has a more powerful democratizing effect among the Southern European countries because it interacts with pressure from major trading partners to democratize. This suggests a revaluation of policies designed to foster the replacement of authoritarian regimes by democratic ones through free trade.

    O'Brien, Kevin J.
  • Rightful Resistance
    Subjects:
    • Government, Resistance to -- China.
    Abstract:
    How is one to understand contentious acts that open channels of participation while also making use of existing channels? Rightful resistance is a partly institutionalized form of popular action that employs laws, policies, and other established values to defy power holders who have failed to live up to some ideal or who have not implemented a popular measure. Analysis of opposition to cadre misconduct in rural China, supported by evidence from the United States, Norway, and South Africa, suggests that resistance can share a common dynamic despite its occurrence in strikingly dissimilar settings. Aggrieved individuals and groups turn to established principles to anchor their defiance; use legitimating myths and normative language to frame their claims; rely on existing statutes and government commitments when leveling their charges; and locate and mobilize advocates within officialdom. In differing contexts, a combination of rights talk, legal tactics, and open confrontation may induce power holders to surrender advantages in accord with principles that usually favor them. The cases examined further suggest that rightful resistance springs from rights consciousness and increases it and, finally, that it may be more consequential than most "everyday resistance" while remaining less risky than wholly uninstitutionalized defiance.

Research Note

    Collier, David, 1942-.
    Mahoney, James.
  • Research Note: Insights and Pitfalls: Selection Bias in Qualitative Research
    Subjects:
    • Comparative government -- Research.
    • Political science -- Research.
    Abstract:
    Qualitative analysts have received stern warnings that the validity of their studies may be undermined by selection bias. This article provides an overview of this problem for qualitative researchers in the field of international and comparative studies, focusing on selection bias that may result from the deliberate selection of cases by the investigator. Examples are drawn from studies of revolution, international deterrence, the politics of inflation, international terms of trade, economic growth, and industrial competitiveness. The article first explores how insights about selection bias developed in quantitative research can most productively be applied in qualitative studies. The discussion considers why qualitative researchers need to be concerned about selection bias, even if they do not care about the generality of their findings, and it considers distinctive implications of this form of bias for qualitative research, as in the problem of what is labeled "complexification based on extreme cases." The article then considers pitfalls in recent discussions of selection bias in qualitative studies. These discussions at times get bogged down in disagreements and misunderstandings over how the dependent variable is conceptualized and what the appropriate frame of comparison should be, issues that are crucial to the assessment of bias within a given study. At certain points it becomes clear that the real issue is not just selection bias, but a larger set of trade-offs among alternative analytic goals.

Review Articles

    Callaghy, Thomas M., ed. Ravenhill, John, ed.
  • Review Article: Hemmed In: Responses to Africa's Economic Decline
    Subjects:
    • Economic assistance -- Africa, Sub-Saharan.
    • Reviewer: Lewis, Peter Michael, 1957-.
    • Review title: Economic reform and political transition in Africa : the quest for a politics of development.
    Abstract:
    The 1980s were bracketed by crises in Africa, as protracted economic malaise was succeeded by a wave of political reform. Analysts have sought to understand the sources of economic decline as well as the political requisites for recovery in the region. Neoclassical and structuralist analyses have been challenged by state-centric views of economic change. The latter perspective emphasizes the need for capable developmental states as a basis for long-term adjustment, but a political theory of economic change is still lacking. Such a theory must address the institutional foundations of growth, as well as the shifting basis of social coalitions in African regimes. Political liberalization suggests the possibility of a new setting for economic reform, though the effects of political reform on institutions and coalitions remain ambiguous, and democratization cannot be regarded as a panacea for the region's developmental failure. Future research must look more closely at the interests and structures in transitional regimes, and scholars should adopt a more comparative vantage on Africa's challenges of reform.
    Hydén, Göran, 1938-, ed.
    Bratton, Michael, ed.
  • Review Article: Governance and Politics in Africa
    Subjects:
    • Africa -- Politics and government -- 1960-.
    • Reviewer: Lewis, Peter Michael, 1957-.
    • Review title: Economic reform and political transition in Africa : the quest for a politics of development.
    Betz, Hans-Georg, 1956-.
  • Review Article: Radical Right-Wing Populism in Western Europe
    Subjects:
    • Political parties -- Europe.
    • Reviewer: Messina, Anthony M.
    • Review title: Not so silent migration : postwar migration to Western Europe.
    Abstract:
    In the 1990s scholars working within the subfield of immigration studies in Western Europe have advanced four major arguments. (1) In a liberal era of global economic markets the capacity of states to govern their territorial borders has significantly eroded. (2) The widespread diffusion of liberal norms has severely inhibited the ability of governments to execute a rational immigrant policy. (3) The experience of mass immigration has transformed the boundaries of national citizenship. And 4) postwar immigration has fostered the surge of radical right-wing populist movements. This article evaluates these arguments in light of the evidence presented in both the collected scholarship under review and other select works. It concludes by arguing the case for new scholarly initiatives to synthesize and unify the separate literatures represented by the volumes under review.




[Journals] [Journal Directory] [Top]